Within a 50 mile radius, you have hundreds of options. I'm not too familiar with the fishing near Toms River, but I know the Raritan to begin with is not too far away. I'm pretty sure every freshwater species of fish you could find in the raritan. The north and south branches of the raritan come together to form the main raritan, and both of them are also excellent fisheries. There are many places on the South Branch that still hold trout. The north branch has a great smallmouth population from Far Hills all the way down to it's confluence with the south branch. The south branch also has some smallmouth and big carp. I know the Toms River should be a stone's throw away and the manasquan river should be close by. I don't fish lakes too often, and never in south jersey or near the ocean, so I couldn't tell you which ones are worthwhile. Try google, it helps.