Welcome to NEFF

Sign up for a new account today, or log on with your old account!

Give us a try!

Welcome back to the new NEFF. Take a break from Twitter and Facebook. You don't go to Dicks for your fly fishing gear, you go to your local fly fishing store. Enjoy!

Delaware Anglers Get Relief from NYC.

This was an article written by David Rossie in the Binghamton "Press and Sun Bulletin" on Sunday. I thought that I would post it here for all of you unfortunate souls that live so far away from the upper Delaware system:)

You can find it on the web, here:

http://www.pressconnects.com/today/sports/stories/sp081703s23216.shtml

Delaware anglers get relief from NYC


DAVID ROSSIE / Press & Sun-Bulletin


For a moment it appeared that Jim Serio might be channeling the ghost of Charles Dickens. "It was the best of times, it was the worst of times."

Well, that's not exactly what Serio said. What he said was this: May saw the best fishing in years on the West Branch of the Delaware River, June saw the worst. More about that later.

Serio knows whereof he speaks. He is a fishing guide on the river and he is founder of the Delaware River Foundation, an organization formed to promote better water management in the Upper Delaware system.

At present, and since 1954, that system has been managed by New York City under the aegis of the Delaware River Basin Commission. The Upper Delaware system, with reservoirs on the east and west branches of the Delaware and on the Neversink River, is the main source of the city's water. The main Delaware winds its way through three other states before it reaches the sea -- Pennsylvania, New Jersey and Delaware -- hence the DRBC.

To prevent salt water in the river's lower reaches from extending upstream past Philadelphia, Pa., and Camden, N.J., the DRBC requires a minimum flow at 1,750 cubic feet per second at Montague, N.J. To help meet that demand, New York City draws a lion's share of Upper Delaware water from the Cannonsville Reservoir on the West Branch because its water is less potable than water from the East Branch and Neversink.

This has resulted over the years in wildly fluctuating releases from the Cannonsville Reservoir, producing feast or famine conditions for aquatic life in the river from Stilesville downstream to the river's junction with the East Branch at Hancock. That is the central reason the Delaware River Foundation came to be.

Last Tuesday the DRF held its third annual Day on the Delaware conference at the West Branch Angler resort at Hale Eddy, midway between Deposit and Hancock. The first two gatherings were marked by frustration and anger over the city's intransigence in matters relating to establishing a reservoir release regimen beneficial to aquatic life and the recreational potential of the West Branch. Tuesday's was guardedly optimistic.

There were signs -- faint but real -- of a thaw in relations between the city and organizations that have come together out of concern for the river's status as a fishery: The DRF, Trout Unlimited, the Nature Conservancy to name a few. But first the Dickens reference.

May's fishing on the West Branch was superb, Serio said, because rainfall was plentiful and Cannonsville was spilling. Instead of being starved for water as is often the case when the 45 cfs winter release program is in effect until June, the river in May was consistently high, which was good for the fish and good for drift boat guides.

Came June, however, and the dam was still spilling, but now it was spilling surface water that had become warm -- too warm. The river remained high, Serio said, but warm water from the reservoir and from feeder streams raised hob with the fly hatches and the fishing suffered. And continued to suffer through July.

Then something good happened. Last weekend, Serio said, the city began voluntarily releasing large amounts of water from the depths of the impoundment, which immediately lowered water temperatures in the river that had been approaching 70 degrees downstream.

That posed no hardship for the city, he noted, in that Cannonsville was at 98 percent of capacity as of Tuesday.

"It would have been nice if they'd done it a month ago," Serio said, "but it's a good sign that they offered to do it."

Some other facts about what New York City is doing with water siphoned off from upstate watersheds:

* New York's per capita daily water consumption is 160 gallons, the highest in the nation. Boston's by contrast is 60 gallons.

* The main aqueduct carrying water to the city from upstate is leaking at an average rate of 37 million gallons a day. That is approximately 13.5 billion gallons a year. The city's Department of Environmental Protection has said it plans to fix the leaks. Someday.

"Whiskey is for drinkin'. Water is for fightin'." Mark Twain.

Rossie is associate editor of the Press & Sun-Bulletin. His Wildlife Watch appears on Sundays.
 
It it feast or famine up there.

FYI, the hatches on the WB the past 45 days has been really lackluster.

The latest info I picked up yesterday is that a New York Biologist doing surveys for research stated that the drawn down after 9/11 caused the massive winter ice scouring of the river bed within the Delaware system. Thus the lackluster hatches. Sounds logical to me because I have been really shocked at the lack of flies.

Hopefully, the releases will stay up forever and give this system a chance to really shine.

As a friend of mine says about the Delaware - "No flies, no targets".

God help the the Catskills.
 
I'm pretty amazed at the comment that the fishing in "May was superb"! It was my worst May in years.

The week I was there it seemed like mid-April at best. Hatches, when they occured, were from 3 PM to 6 PM. A couple of days nothing at all happened. Of course the remaining 75% of the days in May could of been great. What do the rest of you think?
 
NJFred,

I have to tell you that, outside of enjoying the fishing company and the incredible scenery -- the hatching activity has really been really lackluster (once again).

I am hoping that this Fall on the Mainstem is going to be worthwhile.

Did anyone fish the Mainstem the past couple of days? My line of thinking is that it had to be better than the WestBranch.

FYI, those fish have to be eating sometime on something. It has to be on nymphs and streamers in early morning and late at night because no fish of any size, except on one spot yesterday above the Gamelands area, showed. Also, heard story of a huge Brown jumping out of the Mainstem and snatching a BAT out of the sky, injuring it, the bat is flopping on the surface, and this shark came back for the kill. Incredible....

HLR
 
DTW

FYI- The Cannonsville was drawn down to 3% capacity in 2001 because of the drought--- to keep the montaque level at 1750 cfs not because of 9/11.

There was literally no water in the river from the early fall of 2001 until the late spring of 2002 since it was a very very dry fall,winter and spring.No rain or snow.

Because there was no water in the river the insect populations where negativley impacted. No water no bugs!

Think about it if theres no release and theres no rain or snow then where will the water come from?

The main reason was due to no water not ice souring.Where you up ther in the fall/winter and spring of 01/02 to see what the river looked like??

Fred Some of May was great.Also the first three weeks in July was very good as well.
 
Joe T.,

We are sounding like ying and yang. I never stated because of 9/11 the reservoirs were drawn down. I was only providing a time frame of reference, not a potential reason of why the reservoir was drawn down.

I ponders over many things and I have known for many years that no water on any trout system is probably a pretty bad situation. Thanks for walking me through the logic.

If there is no water and there is no measurable precipitation, any water in this system is going to be slow and low. Do you Agree so far? Due to slow and low water -- deeper ice. Makes sense to me and the N.Y. State Biologist.

I find it interesting, however, that until I post the reason for the lackluser density of hatches, fisherman start to respond to this stated opinion by a N.Y. State official.

For whatever it is worth. Thanks for the feedback.

HLR
 
Last edited:
Dtw,

Fyi there has been independant studies done with regards to this situation,and it has been concluded that the insect populations were negativley impacted due to lack of water not ice.

If you remeber it was a warm winter 01/02 and there wasnt much ice if any.I fished all winter long even in the catskills.

If you had seen the river in the fall/winter and spring of 01/02 than you would understand it was because of no water not ice..

Dennis I dont care if president Bush told you this was the reason I was up there in the fall/winter and spring of 01/02 and with my own two eyes saw there was NO WATER and very little ice.


FYI Scouring of ice is from a very cold winter and whats called anchor ice.

Do you happend to know the name of the biologist?Since i would I would love to speak with him about this, or the office he is from?.

Not for anything Dennis I HAVE benn talking about lack luster hatches in the catskills and the reasons for it all dam year.

Dennis if you have not guessed already I am challenging you and your biologist friend to prove me wrong on this one and not for the sake of proving each other wrong but to make sure the readers here get the corect information.
 
Last edited:
I'll certainly buy the decline of insect populations. I also wonder what imapct the lack of alewifes have ment to the fishery. I think the population in the resevior was wiped out when it was drained (I don't think there were hardly any during this year's protracted spill). This has to have been a large chunk of early season protein for the fish, particulary after the long winter when their metabolism slows down.

With all the water this year, one hopes that there will be a rebound in at least the insect population next year.

Once again.... It doesn't sound like anyone else thought "May was great this year!" A couple of great days does not make for a great May.

HLR.. Did not fish the Delaware this weekend but a section of the Tobyhanna. My son and his friend were out paintballing. It was too warm and sunny and thunderstorms kept us from the evening rise. Fishing was dreadful except for one beautiful brookie I picked up in the inlet to a beaver pond. Should of fished that more.
 
I floated from Balls Eddie to Stockport over the weekend. Plenty of action on the WB, however the main stem was dead. Afternoon thunderstorm came through and thought for sure hatch would be on....but nothing! Fog enshrouded the river and left at dark, not seeing one rise.
 
JOE.T said:

Dennis if you have not guessed already I am challenging you and your biologist friend to prove me wrong on this one and not for the sake of proving each other wrong but to make sure the readers here get the corect information.

Come on... Is this really something to get upset about? I mean really... We're talking about bugs here, not politics and women!
 
Back
Top