Welcome to NEFF

Sign up for a new account today, or log on with your old account!

Give us a try!

Welcome back to the new NEFF. Take a break from Twitter and Facebook. You don't go to Dicks for your fly fishing gear, you go to your local fly fishing store. Enjoy!

Catskill Odyssey - 8/9/08

onemorecast

New member
<o:smarttagtype namespaceuri="urn:schemas-microsoft-com<img src=" http:="" www.njflyfishing.com="" vbulletin="" images="" smilies="" redface.gif="" border="0" alt="" title="Embarrassment" smilieid="3" class="inlineimg"></o:smarttagtype>People have different reasons for hiring guides. Some want to be put on big fish, others want a learning experience in a place they’ve never fished before. I belong to the latter category, so in an effort to shorten up my Catskills learning curve, I decided to hire a guide (Dan Ansbach, known as “bkill” on this site) to show me around the <st1>Upper Delaware</st1> system. After a couple of postponements due to weather and flow/temp conditions, we settled on this past Saturday.
<o></o>
Beaverkill-1.jpg

<o></o>
The day started off at the Beaverkill, where we covered one well known spot, Hendrickson’s Pool, and a few nameless spots. Being August, it was no surprise to Dan to find the river devoid of people. Not many bugs, but tricos were doing their thing and my first fish came up for one in the back eddy of Hendrickson’s, despite some rookie mistakes on my part.

After that, it was on to Roscoe, where we stopped by Mary Dette’s shop. It was great to meet her and support her business by buying a bunch of flies. Too many flies. :rolleyes: After a slice of pizza, we went back to fishing.

Casting into tricky currents proved to be the lesson of the day as we moved on to other Beaverkill spots and the Willowemoc where we prospected with big dries in fast water. I missed a hit in one spot, while retrieving my fly and had a nice rainbow break me off in another. Expect the unexpected, I told myself. At the <st1:city w:st="on"><st1>Willow</st1></st1:city>, we threw a mix of dry flies and nymphs, which brought out one fish (landed) and another missed hit. I found the <st1:city w:st="on"><st1>Willow</st1></st1:city> to be very picturesque and we competed for spots with some feathered fish-killers at times. Again, no human anglers on the river.

Willowemoc-1.jpg


<o></o>
After another break, it was off to the East Branch, which told a different story. We spotted didymo in this section, accompanied by these clumps of beige-ish "bunny fur" blooms.


Didymo-1.jpg




We did see anglers on this stretch of water, however, they were few and far between and we could fish wherever we wanted. We attempted stalking a few browns rising to sulphurs in a deep, glassy pool.


EastBranchGlass-1.jpg
<o></o>

Once I was in up to the belt of my leaking waders in 50 degree water, and STILL too far away from the fish, it didn’t take long before I gave up and said “let’s go”. :cold:On the way back downstream, good news! We spotted some more rising fish and the better news was the water we stood in didn’t go past the knees. Despite frozen feet and a bunch of poorly aimed casts across another tough current, I finally drifted a fly right over a steadily rising fish. The head comes up but was it to MY fly? Gee, I’m not sure. I do nothing, while Dan says “Set! Set!” “Oh, that was me?” What a dumb blonde! :bang: How many times have I heard if you can’t see your fly, set the hook if a fish rises anywhere it? Must work on those reflexes! Tie on another, more visible fly (hey – these are old eyes here!) and I finally hook one on a take I could see, a fish with some heft. He threw the hook after less than a minute and that was the end of the fish and the end of our day.
<o></o>
I had stung a bunch and landed two and learned a thing or two about the rivers. I can’t promise I’ll retain it all, but hopefully, over time it will come back to me with each experience. Overall, a fun time in the mountains!

Dan "the Man", rigging me up while I cast dry flies with the spare rod.
IMGP2916-1.jpg


Willow Brownie
Willowbrown-1.jpg


#20 Sulphur, but there were a mix of sizes
SummerSulphur-1.jpg
 
Jessie,

Thanks. That makes me look forward to my trip in Sept.:dizzy:

Hllywd
 
Once I was in up to the belt of my leaking waders in 50 degree water, and STILL too far away from the fish, it didn’t take long before I gave up and said “let’s go”. :cold:On the way back downstream, good news!

50 degrees in the EB? Did u mean "once" as in a long time ago?
 
Last edited:
Nice report Jessie. Looks like you had some fun and learned some new water. Hiring a guide is great if you dont know the water you are going to be fishing. I have done it numerous times and it has helped me tremendously. Now you can go back and repeat the same things you learned on your own. Good luck

TK
 
Forgot to add... nice report.

Liked the photo reports, makes you want to just jump right up, hop in the car and head on up there to fish!
 
Nice report Jessie. Looks like you had some fun and learned some new water. Hiring a guide is great if you dont know the water you are going to be fishing. I have done it numerous times and it has helped me tremendously. Now you can go back and repeat the same things you learned on your own. Good luck

TK

Thanks! I'm looking forward to being able to do that.

Yep - another PA person coming up and fishing those rivers. I'll be so popular! Better start working on my disguise now (and one for my license plate). ;)
 
Nice Report Jesse!! Couldnt have summarized it any better... It was very enjoyable fishing with you...You did a great job on the water!! I am glad you enjoyed the Catskills but I must warn you, they are very addictive...One more word of advice, get rid of the Did Collector:D See ya on the water! D
 
Nice Report Jesse!! Couldnt have summarized it any better... It was very enjoyable fishing with you...You did a great job on the water!! I am glad you enjoyed the Catskills but I must warn you, they are very addictive...One more word of advice, get rid of the Did Collector:D See ya on the water! D

Thank you! I already know about the addiction, you have merely helped make it worse! The Did Collector is already dry as a bone. The waders and boots are another matter.
 
Trust me. :D

Is that an unusual temp for this time of year? I just got back from fishing Idaho, Montana, and Wyoming and I didnt hit any water that cool. Gives me some hope for the Adirondacks this week.. though I know some waters there will be too warm yet. Great report by the way.
 
BIGBOW,
Thinking of doing a fall trip in Oct to the Bighorn River in MT. Did you get a chance to hit that river? Read a recent article in American Angler on the fishing out there. Awesome place with over 7,000 fish per mile. Heard the crowds die down a bit in the fall. Thanks

TK
 
Is that an unusual temp for this time of year? I just got back from fishing Idaho, Montana, and Wyoming and I didnt hit any water that cool. Gives me some hope for the Adirondacks this week.. though I know some waters there will be too warm yet. Great report by the way.

Thanks. Hope you enjoy your ADK trip!
 
Is that an unusual temp for this time of year?


No...The East Branch is a tailwater and the river is quite cold near its release point...Right now (10:50 am) the river is 57 degrees about 15 miles downstream of the reservoir...

I kept a seasonal trailer at a campground on the upper East Branch for years and it was always amusing to watch kids get in tubes to float down the river..We would warn them but they wouldnt listen and sure enough they would last about 10-15 minutes and return shivering and blue...
 
Good for you Jessie getting out there and catching fish. I spent a good part of my childhood on the Beaverkill and it has a special place in my heart.

Also it's great that you got to Mary Dette's shop and got to talk with her. She's an incredibly nice woman with a wealth of fly tying knowledge that I can't even fathom. Next before you go up call a few days ahead and have her tie you some flies herself. They cost a little more but they're beautiful and I consider them a collector's item.

I may be headed up this weekend to take advantage of the great water temps. What did you take those fish on?
 
Tandem nymph rigs were #12 Iso nymph with a #18 Pheasanttail dropper 18-24in below lead fly..(also used size 18 olive emerger and beadhead prince on the dropper)

Trico parachute size 20...Sulphers-parachutes and cripples size 18..

Be prepared with Olives, Iso & Sulphers..

Good Luck this weekend...
 
BIGBOW,
Thinking of doing a fall trip in Oct to the Bighorn River in MT. Did you get a chance to hit that river? Read a recent article in American Angler on the fishing out there. Awesome place with over 7,000 fish per mile. Heard the crowds die down a bit in the fall. Thanks

TK

TK

The horn deserves to toot its own horn every once in a while. I think the last time I fished it was seven or eight years ago. At the time I used to go to MT once a year with the family. After fishing the Big Horn I told myself I would not go back to MT unless I could fish the big horn. One could catch as manny trout as they wished on nymphs or sight fish to fish that could be quite selective. At the time I think the average fish size was something like 17 inches with almost a 50/50 ration of bows to browns.

To say that they have big fish in that river is an understatement. You can rent drift boats in the Area and do your own float. You potentially could have some good dry fly activity along with excelent streamer action at that time.
If you are intrested in a places to stay just shoot me a PM.
 
Back
Top