Welcome to NEFF

Sign up for a new account today, or log on with your old account!

Give us a try!

Welcome back to the new NEFF. Take a break from Twitter and Facebook. You don't go to Dicks for your fly fishing gear, you go to your local fly fishing store. Enjoy!

Pocono rain and Sulphurs

FIN-ITE 34

Well-known member
Curious to hear if anybody else had experience with good Sulphur hatches and cooperating fish during the rain on Sunday. For me, the overcast and rainy day made for some very good midday hatching of large numbers of Sulphurs and March Browns.
The best fishing was during the fairly steady rains from about 1-3 with good numbers of large fish slurping duns as they floated down the river. At one of my stops I was parked under a highway bridge out of the rain where I checked out the river for rising fish. Upstream of the bridge I saw a steady rising fish in the middle of the river, which I thought was odd because most fish I had worked earlier were hugging the bank. I figured it was a small fish and I debated going out after that fish in what was now a fairly heavy rain. But I figured since I was parked under the bridge I could get my gear on out of the rain and decided to give a try on that fish. As I approached closer to the rising fish I could see that it was no dink, but a very respectable fish. I had just tied on a size 12 Sulphur Parachute and made a few casts over the rising fish. On about the fifth drift the fish rose and inhaled my fly. I set the hook and BING, popped off the fly. As I pulled in my line to check the tippet I could see that the line had broken at the knot. So either I tied a bad knot, should have replaced that section of tippet that I had been using all morning, or both. In any event I stood there cussing myself thinking that I had a chance at a real nice fish and I managed to muck it up. Well at about that time the damn fish started to rise again, steadily as if nothing had happened. I thought had the trout gods given me another chance for some good deed I may have done? So I replaced the tippet with a new section tied to the tippet ring and tied on a another size 12 parachute. Well I drifted over that fish at least a dozen times without ever a refusal. I started to think that I had blown my chance and with that I noticed some March Browns mixed in with the Sulphurs, so I changed to a Catskill style March Brown ala Matt Grobert. Two drifts later............

Photo537.jpg

This fat pig.

The day produced a number of fish up to twenty inches and a good bunch of smaller fish that I attribute to the inclement weather. It was wet, but it was a fun day.
 
Pretty good weekend all around from Friday to Sunday. Didn't see much rain in the Poconos but good cloud cover, lots of bugs, steady risers all weekend. Also lots of people on some spots. Sunday had good cornutas mixed with sulphurs, March Browns, and the beginning of the ISO hatch:)
Curious to hear if anybody else had experience with good Sulphur hatches and cooperating fish during the rain on Sunday. For me, the overcast and rainy day made for some very good midday hatching of large numbers of Sulphurs and March Browns.
The best fishing was during the fairly steady rains from about 1-3 with good numbers of large fish slurping duns as they floated down the river. At one of my stops I was parked under a highway bridge out of the rain where I checked out the river for rising fish. Upstream of the bridge I saw a steady rising fish in the middle of the river, which I thought was odd because most fish I had worked earlier were hugging the bank. I figured it was a small fish and I debated going out after that fish in what was now a fairly heavy rain. But I figured since I was parked under the bridge I could get my gear on out of the rain and decided to give a try on that fish. As I approached closer to the rising fish I could see that it was no dink, but a very respectable fish. I had just tied on a size 12 Sulphur Parachute and made a few casts over the rising fish. On about the fifth drift the fish rose and inhaled my fly. I set the hook and BING, popped off the fly. As I pulled in my line to check the tippet I could see that the line had broken at the knot. So either I tied a bad knot, should have replaced that section of tippet that I had been using all morning, or both. In any event I stood there cussing myself thinking that I had a chance at a real nice fish and I managed to muck it up. Well at about that time the damn fish started to rise again, steadily as if nothing had happened. I thought had the trout gods given me another chance for some good deed I may have done? So I replaced the tippet with a new section tied to the tippet ring and tied on a another size 12 parachute. Well I drifted over that fish at least a dozen times without ever a refusal. I started to think that I had blown my chance and with that I noticed some March Browns mixed in with the Sulphurs, so I changed to a Catskill style March Brown ala Matt Grobert. Two drifts later............

View attachment 12345

This fat pig.

The day produced a number of fish up to twenty inches and a good bunch of smaller fish that I attribute to the inclement weather. It was wet, but it was a fun day.
 
Last edited:
I had just tied on a size 12 Sulphur Parachute and made a few casts over the rising fish.

I set the hook and BING, popped off the fly.

As I pulled in my line to check the tippet I could see that the line had broken at the knot. So either I tied a bad knot, should have replaced that section of tippet that I had been using all morning, or both.

Well at about that time the damn fish started to rise again, steadily as if nothing had happened.

I thought had the trout gods given me another chance for some good deed I may have done?

So I replaced the tippet with a new section tied to the tippet ring and tied on a another size 12 parachute.

Two drifts later............

Yeah, yeah, yeah...
But did you get the original "size 12 Sulphur Parachute" back?

If the Trout Gods were indeed smiling on you for some good deed you may have done, they woulda "finagled" it so you would have gotten back that first, lost fly...
 
I have to hand it to you guys. I can't recall ever catching a fish on a Sulphur dun. I have always fished them on a tandem rig with a emerger trailing behind the Dun. It seems the fish always take the emerger, never the Dun. I don't know if the color of my Sulphers are off. I have no luck with them.
 
I have to hand it to you guys. I can't recall ever catching a fish on a Sulphur dun. I have always fished them on a tandem rig with a emerger trailing behind the Dun. It seems the fish always take the emerger, never the Dun. I don't know if the color of my Sulphers are off. I have no luck with them.


That's odd Tom - sulphur duns stay on the water longer than other species because their wings take longer to dry. This makes sulphur duns more appealing to trout than the duns of basically any other mayfly.

I will say though, that trout can be picky when there are a lot of sulphurs on the water, and will only take crippled emergers. But just the same, I've had more luck on sulphur duns than on any other dun over the years.

Do you tie yours flush? That might be important. I remember fishing a catskill tied sulphur dun a few years back on the Lackawaxen during a big sulphur hatch and not even getting refusals from stockies. Haven't fished one since - strictly comparaduns or low-riding patterns with parachutes.
 
That's odd Tom - sulphur duns stay on the water longer than other species because their wings take longer to dry. This makes sulphur duns more appealing to trout than the duns of basically any other mayfly.

I will say though, that trout can be picky when there are a lot of sulphurs on the water, and will only take crippled emergers. But just the same, I've had more luck on sulphur duns than on any other dun over the years.

Do you tie yours flush? That might be important. I remember fishing a catskill tied sulphur dun a few years back on the Lackawaxen during a big sulphur hatch and not even getting refusals from stockies. Haven't fished one since - strictly comparaduns or low-riding patterns with parachutes.


I have used Catskill ties in the "petting zoo" to great success, but according to some a piece if yellow yarn with a hook would work there.....I should take some of you there as the trout have become more selective....the best pattern for sulphurs I have found is Grobert's soft hackle pheasant tail emerger...fish it dry, it sits in the film, fish cannot refuse it, and I don't know if I can remember a good drift where one has.....before the hatch starts, fish it wet.....Tom.....never caught a fish on a Sulphur dun? WTF man?:)
 
Back
Top