No there are no bullet proof waders I know of.
I bought a pair of the Simms guide weight waders almost two years ago and I have repaired almost 20 holes since.
I went with Simms because of there "bullet proof" reputation.
Granted I fish a lot and do walk off the beat and path.So I could understand the "holes"However The worst part is the seams are now leaking and Simms will not Replace the waders they want to try and fix them.For the money I SPENT THEY SHOULD TAKE THEM BACK.I really hope they do since I WOULD LIKE TO GIVE A SECOND PAIR A CHANCE.
I have returned 5 pairs of Orvis waders over the years with NO question asked.And have gotten back 5 pairs of waders at no charge.
Patagonia also takes back everything and replaces it with a new product for no charge as well.
In fact I am in the process of sending back my wading boots (Patagonia)after 31 months of use.Believe it or not I called them today and told them the felt had come lose and the trim around the bottom of the boots had worn off.The guy Dave said "well send them in and and if your not attached to the boots we will send you a new pair"!(Free).My intention at first was just to send them in to get new felt put on.And now a pair of new boots.That 160.00 is going a long way!
Because I fish so much I put a tremendous amount of wear and tear on my equipment,so my main concern is not just quality but the return policy as well.
Sometimes it worth the extra few bucks for things in the long run.
Fanatic
The breathable waders from Orvis are good for the money not just the silver label but the lower line ones as well.You may be returning them yearly with leaks,but you will have a new pair every year!