Well I read both, and even managed to learn some more about a process I admittedly don't know all that much about. I'm certainly not denying that it is a valuable energy resource that we need to utilize. I recognize that, but I also want to be sure that the regulatory agencies are up to speed in order to deal properly and adequately with their tasks associated with Marcellus Shale gas extraction. Right now, in PA, (I can't really speak to NY) I don't think the Keystone State agencies are prepared as much as they need to be (I actually think the PFBC recognizes this fact.) I worry less about the drilling itself and more about other apects associated with the process (namely the storage, treatment, and disposal of frac water as well as more gravel access roads which can and do lead to more siltation of exceptional value headwater streams in the regions.) I mean, I think you would probably agree, that with some of the reports the treatment and disposal issue in PA is already looking at least a little bleak (and with the cuts to PADEP it's probably only going to get worse.)

__________________
Trout Unlimited, Forks of the Delaware Chapter